x
Close

Alex McMinn on making regulatory reform work

Alex McMinn standing against a dark green background, wearing a grey suit and light blue shirt.

How do you prove a regulator is doing its job when its greatest successes are things that never happen?

Alex McMinn is head of regulatory system capability at New Zealand’s Ministry for Regulation. He joins Simon Corden and Paul Leavoy on The Modern Regulator (TMR) Podcast to discuss how reviews can lead to reform, what performance measures miss, and why senior regulatory leaders sometimes need a confidential place to ask for help.

Building on our earlier conversation with McMinn, this episode gets into the practical work of improving regulatory institutions. The ministry’s review approach brings ministers, agencies, and affected communities into the conversation while a review is still under way. The aim is to build support for change before the report lands, without allowing momentum to outrun the evidence.

Measuring the results presents another challenge. More problems detected can make a regulator’s performance look worse. Effective enforcement can leave regulated businesses less satisfied. McMinn explains why inspection counts and processing times matter, but cannot tell leaders whether the harms they exist to prevent are actually falling.

The conversation also examines a peer advisory panel pilot that would give regulatory leaders frank advice from experienced colleagues. The ministry would help bring the group together, then step out of the room so difficult problems can be discussed candidly.

In this episode:

  • Why training individual practitioners needs to be matched by investment in leadership and governance
  • How reviews can build a coalition for change before their recommendations are published
  • What hairdressing and residential solar reveal about choosing a review’s scope
  • Why evidence about harm and engagement with less-heard voices must survive the pressure for speed
  • How testing a diagnosis with people likely to disagree can prevent premature consensus
  • Why effective regulation can look unsuccessful on a generic public service scorecard
  • What the peer advisory panel pilot could offer leaders facing difficult decisions
  • McMinn’s magic wand answer: making prevented harm visible

Reading mentioned in the episode

  • Alex McMinn’s Policy Quarterly article, Don’t build a profession, govern a system: rethinking regulatory capability, on the leadership and governance needed alongside workforce training
  • The New Zealand Productivity Commission’s 2014 report, Regulatory institutions and practices, recommended by both McMinn and Corden
  • Artificial intelligence, regulatory capacity, and the adaptive state, the paper Corden discusses in the episode’s introduction

Listen below, or on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts.

Subscribe to TMR’s newsletter for monthly analysis and practitioner insight. Follow TMR on LinkedIn for new episodes and articles.

Picture of Paul Leavoy

Paul Leavoy

The Modern Regulator Managing Editor Paul Leavoy is a seasoned journalist and regulatory analyst with over two decades of experience writing about technology, public policy, and regulation.

Related Posts

POPULAR POSTS

Stay ahead of regulation

News, insight, and analysis weekly

STAY INFORMED